Form 3L Alternatives


#1

I know there has been discussion about this from some users - but I’m curious if anyone has used other low cost SLA/MSLA/DLP machines for engineering applications.

Phrozen is coming out with a Mega 8K MSLA machine. Wondering what people’s experiences have been with other similar machines (Phrozen Transform, etc.)

I would specifically be interested in knowing:

  • Quality of engineering resins
  • Ease of use
  • Post-processing - how big are the touch points, do they peel off easily, how much cleanup is required
  • Maintenance - how long do these “mono” LCD screens last? Are they a pain to replace?

https://phrozen3d.com/pages/sonic-mega-8k-preorder


#2

That’s great, I’ve been waiting for a large-scale, 8K mono printer.

There’s a bit of discussion here on Reddit and on the Facebook group.

  • Printer Size: 40cm (length) x 47cm (width) x 68cm (height)
  • Build Volume: 33cm x 18.5cm x 40cm (height)
  • 15" screen
  • up to 70mm/hr print speed
  • 43um pixel size
  • nobody seems to know the Z-resolution

#3

Yeah - I think the challenge is that 80% of the people on those groups are hobbyists who are doing ad-hoc figurines and stuff, which isn’t super helpful for us engineering folk.


#4

I have the Phrozen Transform since fall 2019. I use it for big and long parts. You can use multiple brands of resins. Not only the Phrozen ones. Of course they are cheaper than FL. I did many parts for my customer, who is casting urethane molds.
I will probably buy this Sonic Mega 8K bundle. And I will sell my Transform, which is in a great condition and with many spare parts. Also, the Phrozen Cure Mega is interesting for his great volume and low price. In comparaison of the Form 3L cure.


#5

@BILLUCAS what are your touchpoint sizes on the Transform for large parts?

Yes, I was also looking at the Cure Mega as an alternative depending when it comes out.


#6

For larges parts, it’s around 1.5mm touchpoint size. In chitubox, you can adjust them as you like.
This morning, I bought the Cure Mega. Supposed to comes out in august.
I was not able to buy there Early Bird special this morning. Maybe I will buy 2 Sonic Mega and sell the other one.
Or, I will buy only one, shipped in october. Or buy from the Alberta reseller next fall.
The worst of all, is there Fedex shipping prices. It’s really expensive.
I bought the Cure Mega 499$ US + 399$ US shipping.
Overall, with the rebate, the price is good.

Phrozen Cure Mega comes with 40 X 40 X 45cm mega chamber size.


#7

Holy that’s a HUGE touchpoint size! Post processing must suck :frowning_face:

I decided to wait on the Cure Mega since it won’t be out until August anyway.

Let us know how it goes when you get the Cure Mega and if you end up buying a Mega 8K!


#8

This touchpoint size is for big heavy parts. It depends what is the part and where we put the touchpoints. It’s between 0.5 - 1.5 mm. Mostly on a none visible surface, of course. So, it’s not to bad for me.

The dimensional accuracy is good too. But I don’t measure all the 3d printed parts all the time, if it’s not critical. It depends on the resin you have. More tweaking is necessary for exposure time of resins.
DLP is great for speed. Only the number of layers and exposure will change your printing time. Whatever the number of parts on the build plate.
But you have to pour resin in the vat yourself.
You only have to change the FEP film. Less garbage.
Each type of printers for type of jobs.


#9

How was the dimensional accuracy? I guess I fall in the “engineering” category as well since musical instruments require insane precision, and that’s why I went with Formlabs (also had used form 2 for years)


#10

Right. I’m usually pushing 0.3-0.4mm on all parts, even really large ones on the Form 3L, so 1.5mm sounded really large.

I’ll definitely be keeping tabs on the Mega 8K for now.


#11

I admit. You can have a lot of supports and a small touchpoint size. And less supports with bigger points too. I think.
With Phrozen Aqua 4K Resin, I’ve made great parts for my customers. Also, they have the Onyx Rigid Pro410 resin. I didn’t tried but seems to be good for industrial use, or engineering category. You can buy them on Amazon, or other resellers.

Update: I finally bought the Sonic Mega 8K! I will get it in october, or more…
A complement for the Form 3L, with another technology.

I will probably sell my Form 2 and my Phrozen Transform.
And later, I would like the Fuse 1 ! :smiley: